Saturday, July 23, 2011

How to Make a Great Chocolate Chip Cookie : 9 Tips, Tricks & Why My Wife Asks Me to Make Them


I have no doubts that I will be ridiculed to the furthest extent of what's imaginable for writing this blog entry. Let's just call it my attempt to divulge my biggest baking secrets while increasing my readership beyond immediate family members.

I'd like to offer up 9 tips to baking what my wife would refer to as a "great" cookie.  With a baby on the way, I will cook, clean, bake, run, do anything for her as long as she is able to rest easy at night with a full belly.  This is my best insight into how to bake a delicious cookie that stays soft and chewy many days after just in case there happens to be an "emergency".

1. (OVEN) Always preheat the oven - although this is an explicit instruction with any cookie recipe, if you're still reading, then you might be the kind of person who should follow this

2. (SUGAR) Use a full cup of brown sugar - most recipes I've seen ask for 3/4 cup of both granulated and brown sugar - brown sugar is soft and would pack down to 3/4 if you tried to pack it - skip it and just throw a full cup in the there.

3. (SALT) Sprinkle vs. adding all at once - add a little more than a teaspoon of salt to your recipe.  Salt is an underrated component of the cookie ingredients because sweet is the only anticipated outcome - adding the salt in pinches will spread it out and will lead to a balanced flavor.

4. (MIX) Mix all ingredients prior to adding the flour and chocolate chips - in my opinion, the cookie base is everything but the flour and the chocolate chips - you should have a smooth consistency before adding.

5. (FLOUR)* Add gradually...amount can vary - I've seen recipes that range from 2 1/4 to 3 1/4 cups of flour.  This variability is what can probably throw things off.  Key here is to add it gradually until the dough doesn't stick to your hands - this is how the next step will work in your favor.  I also tend to believe that flour amounts actually change depending on the temperature of your surroundings.  Less flour needed in a cooler environment.  Call me crazy.

6. (ROLL) Don't clump it...roll it - Although at first I thought this might be just for aesthetics, I'm convinced cookies bake better if they cook evenly - rolling them into a ball before baking them seems logical to me since the cookie will form more evenly while baking - scoop the dough with a regular sized spoon and roll into a small ball (a little bigger than a golf ball).  The shape will also help with the next tip.

7. (SPACE) Give them room - It's probably best to try to get 12 cookies per sheet and get two batches plus an overrun for a large cookie (Pizookie-esque).  This will help them keep their form when you're pulling them off the sheet.  If you go with a Pizookie - buy Vanilla Bean ice cream.

8. (BAKE & WATCH)* Supervise - Cookies don't need to completely bake in the oven - watch them around the 7-8 minute mark and they should start to sweat/shine on the top - pull them out about a minute after you see them glisten.

9. (SLAM) Make noise - since you pull the cookies out a little early they need to come down and finish baking.  I take the cookie sheet out of the oven and drop it on the stove top (one edge already down) so that the cookies cave a bit.  This is my favorite part along with sampling the cookie dough, eating the warm cookies and seeing the smile on my wife's face.

* I would consider these steps the highest priority

Everything else should take care of itself.

As this is my best cookie guidance, let me know how it goes in the comments section.

10 comments:

Louisa said...

I 100% agree with there being different consistencies based on environment. My cookies have not been as perfect here in AZ. A little soupy/runny. I've been considering whether it might be the temperature of my butter?

Question:

- brown sugar - so are you saying 3/4c packed, or 1c loose? Or are you actually saying increase to 1c packed? I'm interested by this recipe alteration bc I have always used 3/4 c packed.

Raniel said...

Sis/Only Reader - I would go with 1C loose and go a little heavier on the flour until it doesn't stick to your hand or spoon.

Louisa said...

Okay! I will try that...one thing I never do is add the flour a little at a time. Funny - I just assume the Giradelli recipe is tried & true from all these years.

1 c brown sugar loose. Can't wait to try it!

Anonymous said...

Raniel, you do make the best chocolate chip cookies EVER. I like your analysis of the flour and salt; quantities. process and environment... But haven't you've tweaked your recipe just a bit? Didn't you used to say the timing of adding the chips was crucial? I thought you used to put them in earlier so they could slightly break up in the mixing? My memory could be faulty, however...
Mom

Patti said...

Oh my goodness! At long last, Raniel reveals his legendary chocolate chip cookie baking secrets! I seriously never thought it would happen in my lifetime. I imagined if I were lucky I could pull the crumpled sheet of paper out of your folded hands, still gripping them coldly in your coffin (sorry, that got a little morbid)

Anyways, your baking prowess has been a legend in the family and I'm honored to have the chance to attempt to emulate it. Thanks for the post!

Louisa said...

: blog window open

: mixer on

: oven preheating

Buddy Jacob said...

I'll excpect a huge batch at the next NASCAR extravaganza at your place!

savage said...

Well, today we tried your tips for flawless, angelic, demigod-level, makes-passers-by-crash-their-cars-and-walk-away-from-the-burning-wreckage-untouched-because-they-were-protected-by-their-intense-desire-for-these-masterful-life-changing-cookies cookies, and we found your tips to be exactly what you promised. The cookies were great. Thanks for posting the tips, my cookie eating experience will be forever darkened by this immense peak of cookie eating experiences, to which no other cookie will ever compare.

-Liam

Patti said...

Tried the cookie secrets. In short: works like a charm (see above rave review). Prediction: the batch won't make it through a second day. :)

Courtney said...

Raniel - I had no idea you had a blog, however, it makes total sense for you! :-) Going to use your chocolate chip cookie tricks. You take such good care of your beautiful wife - please pass along those tips to my husband! Miss you guys!