 |
| Waiting Giordano's pizzza I took shots from the top of the Hancock Center |
I had a work trip in Chicago and developed a hankerin' for some pizza. In hindsight, "some" may have been a bit of an understatement. The background here is that my first night in town we ended up at a tapas restaurant of all places. In my opinion, tapas could be one of the worst ideas known to mankind if you're hungry and with a large group of people. Anything that comes out gets only marginally scrutinized, gets shared (i.e. one sorry excuse for a nibble) and then devoured. To add to that, there's so many different flavors running around the table that one is bound to get some form of indigestion mid/post- meal, but I digress...
Back to the pizza, first meal was immediately following the tapas episode that included more plates than I cared to see. I had heard during our sorry excuse for a meal that there were a couple great Chicago pizzerias within striking distance on Superior. So, we ended up going to Gino's East for my first experience with real Chicago deep-dish pizza. Next day, it was a sneak-out lunch back to GE for lunch - vendor was buying and then knocked out a late fourth meal at Giordano's. Next day was a trip to Lou Malnati's which I had previously enjoyed via dry ice delivery from their website (
http://www.loumalnatis.com/ - you won't be disappointed - just not cheap). After a 48-hour trip I managed to eat pizza five different times and thought I'd provide a little run-down on my thoughts.
 |
| I sat on the corner and enjoyed some World Famous Stuffed Pizza with Carl from 27th St. |
I had to rank the pizza on a number of levels because a Chicago pizza became a little more mysterious and complex the more I dabbled in the details. This is only one person's attempt at an independent third-party analysis and I'm sure there will be some debate (or, perhaps new pizzeria entrants that I need to try the next time around)
Gino's East / Giordano's / Lou Malnati's
CHEESE
2 / 1 / 3
(Giordano's got the top rank here because their World Famous Stuffed Pizza was loaded with cheese - loaded. Cheese lovers should probably post up on this corner of the world)
SAUCE
1 / 2 / 2
(The sauce at Gino's East got high marks for its flavor - really good)
MEAT (Pepperoni)
1 / 3 / 2
(GE took this one too because of its unique pepperoni flavor and cut)
CRUST
2* / 3 / 1
(This is where it got complicated --- I asterisk Gino's East because the crust was exactly what you'd hope and dream for in the form of a deep dish. My only issue with it as, well as Giordano's, was that the size of the crust created a two-part approach to each slice. There's almost no way to really get the pizza body paired with a bite of crust. The East crust was amazing, dense and almost ate like a separate meal. At one point I thought I was doing it a favor, but I was wrong. Here's the rub (not a pun) - the crust at Lou's was buttered...and although it was deep dish thickness from top to bottom, it was thin enough to couple with the fixings)
CONSISTENCY
2 / 3 / 1
(Looking at all of it I realized that I came to the table with a need for some level of consistency of flavor. This is where Lou Malnati's really delivered. Crust wasn't overwhelming - buttery goodness and the ingredient balance was truly a work of art - each item didn't stand out but together made for a mean slice of pepperoni)
 |
My Top Pick - best balance and the butter crust -
ask for bartender Quinn and tell her I sent you |
My Overall Chicago Pizzeria Rankings :
#3 - Giordano's
# 2 - Gino's East
#1 - Lou Malnati's
Just my take. Any other takes are more than welcome. Either way, Chicago style deep-dish pizza has found new favor with me. Chicago pizza will more likely than not be served in heaven - there may be a form of tapas --- in hell.
...that's neither here nor there