Wednesday, June 15, 2011

Pandora's IPO

(Warning: this is not investment advice)
(Other Warning: this is not as nonsensical as might be expected by the 1 or 2 people that read this blog)

When I found out a few weeks ago that Pandora was going to go public I was pretty excited about the financial implications of getting in early on a company whose valuation may take a while to nail down.  I sent out the email to a couple guys at work and sloppily estimated that the stock would trade somewhere in the neighborhood of $20/share.  Well - today was the day - and, it's been up over $20 and now below $20 and who knows where it's going to go from here?  CNBC had a separate ticker on the stock this morning on the top of the screen and the naysayers were already out in full force scratching their heads in disbelief because Pandora has yet to turn a profit.  It was decent skeptical energy for a Wednesday.  A great break from all of the positive news out there.

I'm a big fan of Pandora - I use the service every single day.  I'm listening to Pandora right now.  Although I've come to learn that just because I use something doesn't mean that it makes for a great business.

After thinking a little about it, there's at least three major reasons for why I think Pandora has a sustainable business model that get a little less attention than the commentaries I've heard so far:

  • The masses would much rather not pay for something that they know that they can get for free 
  • With the subscriber base of Pandora closing in on 100M users - advertisers will pay more for the ability to access a highly targeted audience vs. other low impact mediums
  • It's much easier to let someone or something manage your music and recommendations than having to do it yourself - be lazy

People Don't Want to Pay for Music 
The genius of Apple is that they convinced the entire world to buy a fancy thumb drive called an iPod.  We we still had to purchase the music, organize the playlists and spend time syncing to lock it all in. I've bought my fair share of iPods over the years and now realize that most of them are collecting dust.  Maybe I'm bored with my music collection or just way too into my Pandora radio on my BlackBerry - I'm just struggling with why I would go to iTunes and download another song. In Pandora I can simply enter the song or artist that I want to listen to and BAM...there it is.  Can someone explain why people will keep spending their hard earned dollars on more iTunes songs or other paid music services?

If People Don't Want to Pay for Music - Corporations Will
With top-tier advertisers (McDonald's, Taco Bell, Lowes, Petsmart, Farmer's Insurance, etc.) in the mix, I've got to believe that Pandora is making a real run at profitability now more than ever and the nice thing is that they more than subsidize my listening experience.  Plus - the advertising is high impact - you've got a captive ear for the most part and how many Pandora users can get the "WE ARE FARMERS...dun du du dun dun -- dun dun" out of their head?  I'm okay with advertising in this space - it's a good trade.  Plus, it's geocoded as far as I know which means that they have a platform for extension of their ads on a local basis similar to Groupon and Living Social.  Unlike those start-ups, Pandora has the scale to be effective.


Pandora's Music Genome Project Means I Don't Have to Invest as Much Time Exploring
I used to spend a good amount of time on amazon.com trying to find music recommendations from other users.  Then along comes Pandora...and the rest seems like history.  Although it was slightly gratifying to find new artists myself - I'm just as appreciative of others helping me with the selection process with their thumbs up and thumbs down.  I'm trying to become less of a traditionalist when it comes to music consumption.  Or, perhaps the path is the least resistant.  I used to think it was important to listen to an artist's album in its entirety and pay the $9.99-$12.99 to validate that the artist had indeed nailed it.  Pretty sure I'm yielding that stance.  Technology is allowing me to simply give up, sit back and enjoy the endless shuffle of artists with similar musical attributes. Not going to fight it.

Only time will tell how Pandora will do as a profit generating business.  They've built a great service so far.  For now, I'm just going to keep listening to this new Mumford & Sons radio station I set up because the hits keep coming.




4 comments:

A. Contador said...

Great Post Raniel. You put into words exactly what I was thinking.

The Big Johnson said...

(I don't want to pay for music) + (I love listening to music) + (I love discovering new music based on my music taste) + (I don't mind watching/listening to ads every now and then) = Me loving Pandora

Proud owner of 50 shares, my cost basis is down 12% currently.

Anonymous said...

Ummmm Danny just got really excited - he wants to buy Pandora stock. I feel like this could be a future Netflix - a model that just takes over the media world of its kind. - Louisa

Anonymous said...

Costco or Pandora, Raniel???
Mom