This is one of those blog rants that requires some level of commentary effort by at least the founding fathers of this nonsense that I post on a semi-monthly basis (or, is bi-monthly?). Anyway, I know that technology has come a long way since the days of Warren Moon and those sweet jail bird ref unies, but I have to say I think I am convinced of at least one thing when it comes to football and my recent viewing of way too much of it - instant replay is killing the game.
First off, I have to say I'm not a huge football fan to begin with so the only reason I'm watching is to confirm that I actually control the sports world with carefully timed bets that are sure to never pay off, but guarantee that my money is given to someone else much wiser than I. In addition, I'm sure there are all kinds of great reasons to like taking a 15 minute break every 5 minutes to wait for someone to watch about a thousand different angles of the same play to verify that yes, they aren't doing their job well - I however, am not one of them.
Questionable officiating is about as deeply rooted in sport's history and sports itself. I will confess this now (you probably saw this coming) I am a Sacramento Kings fan and yes, I know what happened in the 2002 NBA Western Conference Finals. I could have used some good instant replay then and a set of hand cuffs for Tim Donaghy, but that is a different sport and a conversation for a different time.
With football, it now has become quite evident that we are willing to not only completely slow down the game to validate these officiating shortcomings, but we're also forced to wait an absurd amount of time while everyone on the field takes a water break, a couple butt pats/high fives and we're forced to stare at the head coach as he ponders why he is even on the field when the entire game is being called by the guys upstairs.
It's not that I entirely disagree with the concept of instant replay. My growing beef with it is that is has ceased to be "instant". I'm not looking to watch speed football (although my wife would be a big fan), but I would suggest that momentum in sports is everything. When teams get mini rest breaks a few times a game to collect their thoughts after crucial plays - momentum dies a slow painful death. Is there any way for football to have some sort of super replay ref who sits in the booth and can make the call on the spot and send it to the field without any delay? It seems like the guys announcing the game can figure it out 89% of the time after the first couple replays...some better than others, thus the 11% uncertainty. After all, even sometimes after the call is made, we know that they still didn't make the right call. The worst call of the season so far (Bill Walton would say "in the history of the NFL and the instant replay") - Calvin Johnson against the Bears - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ArDyByR5GVA&feature=related
So we sat at lunch today mowing greasy sandwiches because we had a coupon for it, and it was here where I heard great arguments both ways from two very wise gentlemen (to remain nameless for now - let's just say they're the founding fathers that I referenced earlier). It seems that there is at least some opinion surrounding the benefit or detriment of the instant replay booth. I, for one, simply want the teams that I pick to win and cover the normal over that I get suckered into with or without the help of gratuitous challenge flags being thrown (Baylor, Utah, Stanford - that meant you this weekend). This may be a selfish reason, but as we all know, momma needs a new pair of shoes and a full-time job just doesn't cover it anymore.Can we have it in the comments section for a little while and get to the bottom of this? Or, will this just be another post that gets added to the growing archive labeled "complete waste of time"?

1 comment:
Adapt, accept and move on. As long as they get the call right, I'd rather have a "momentum killer" cost someone a game versus a bad call. Can't wait until we have a chip in the ball and sensors in every yard line so we always know exactly where the ball is. You heard it here first folks...
Post a Comment