Monday, August 30, 2010

My Chicago Pizza Ratings


Waiting Giordano's pizzza I took shots from the top of the Hancock Center
 I had a work trip in Chicago and developed a hankerin' for some pizza.  In hindsight, "some" may have been a bit of an understatement.  The background here is that my first night in town we ended up at a tapas restaurant of all places.  In my opinion, tapas could be one of the worst ideas known to mankind if you're hungry and with a large group of people.  Anything that comes out gets only marginally scrutinized, gets shared (i.e. one sorry excuse for a nibble) and then devoured.  To add to that, there's so many different flavors running around the table that one is bound to get some form of indigestion mid/post- meal, but I digress...

Back to the pizza, first meal was immediately following the tapas episode that included more plates than I cared to see.  I had heard during our sorry excuse for a meal that there were a couple great Chicago pizzerias within striking distance on Superior.  So, we ended up going to Gino's East for my first experience with real Chicago deep-dish pizza.  Next day, it was a sneak-out lunch back to GE for lunch - vendor was buying and then knocked out a late fourth meal at Giordano's.  Next day was a trip to Lou Malnati's which I had previously enjoyed via dry ice delivery from their website (http://www.loumalnatis.com/ - you won't be disappointed - just not cheap).  After a 48-hour trip I managed to eat pizza five different times and thought I'd provide a little run-down on my thoughts.

I sat on the corner and enjoyed some World Famous Stuffed Pizza with Carl from 27th St.

I had to rank the pizza on a number of levels because a Chicago pizza became a little more mysterious and complex the more I dabbled in the details.  This is only one person's attempt at an independent third-party analysis and I'm sure there will be some debate (or, perhaps new pizzeria entrants that I need to try the next time around)

Gino's East / Giordano's / Lou Malnati's                       
CHEESE               
2         /       1         /          3
(Giordano's got the top rank here because their World Famous Stuffed Pizza was loaded with cheese - loaded.  Cheese lovers should probably post up on this corner of the world)

SAUCE                    
1          /       2         /          2
(The sauce at Gino's East got high marks for its flavor - really good)

MEAT (Pepperoni)    
1          /       3         /          2
(GE took this one too because of its unique pepperoni flavor and cut)

CRUST                     
2*        /       3         /          1
(This is where it got complicated --- I asterisk Gino's East because the crust was exactly what you'd hope and dream for in the form of a deep dish.  My only issue with it as, well as Giordano's, was that the size of the crust created a two-part approach to each slice.  There's almost no way to really get the pizza body paired with a bite of crust.  The East crust was amazing, dense and almost ate like a separate meal.  At one point I thought I was doing it a favor, but I was wrong.  Here's the rub (not a pun) - the crust at Lou's was buttered...and although it was deep dish thickness from top to bottom, it was thin enough to couple with the fixings)

CONSISTENCY       
2          /        3         /          1
(Looking at all of it I realized that I came to the table with a need for some level of consistency of flavor.  This is where Lou Malnati's really delivered.  Crust wasn't overwhelming - buttery goodness and the ingredient balance was truly a work of art - each item didn't stand out but together made for a mean slice of pepperoni)

My Top Pick - best balance and the butter crust -
ask for bartender Quinn and tell her I sent you
My Overall Chicago Pizzeria Rankings :              

 #3 - Giordano's

# 2 - Gino's East

 #1 - Lou Malnati's         

Just my take.  Any other takes are more than welcome.  Either way, Chicago style deep-dish pizza has found new favor with me.  Chicago pizza will more likely than not be served in heaven - there may be a form of tapas --- in hell.

...that's neither here nor there

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Beneficial info and excellent design you got here! I want to thank you for sharing your ideas and putting the time into the stuff you publish! Great work!

Anonymous said...

My partner and I really enjoyed reading this blog post, I was just itching to know do you trade featured posts? I am always trying to find someone to make trades with and merely thought I would ask.

Raniel said...

Oddly enough, I actually have no idea what a "trade of featured posts" is...should I? Perhaps you can enlighten me? Thanks for reading!

Anonymous said...

Couldnt agree more with that, very attractive article

Anonymous said...

Beneficial info and excellent design you got here! I want to thank you for sharing your ideas and putting the time into the stuff you publish! Great work!